Pharmacy bodies lose final legal challenge to fight pharmacy cuts

The Pharmaceutical Services Negotiating Committee lost its Court of Appeal judgment on 23 August 2018, meaning that the cuts to community pharmacy in 2016 were not unlawful.

The Pharmaceutical Services Negotiating Committee (PSNC) has said it gained “useful insight” into government thinking despite

The Court of Appeal ruled on 23 August 2018 that appeals by both the PSNC and the National Pharmacy Association (NPA) against a previous High Court decision rejecting their applications for a judicial review were not upheld.

The decision, from three Court of Appeal judges, means that government cuts imposed in October 2016 will remain in place until a new community pharmacy contract is agreed.

But Bharat Patel, vice-chair of the PSNC, said the long legal process had helped to highlight “important ways” in which future consultations on community pharmacy funding should be carried out.

“Through the judicial review process, we have also gained some useful insight into Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) thinking and the challenges that are ahead for all of us as the NHS tries to set out a ten-year plan that meets rising demand and embraces innovations such as digital models of care,” he said.

Patel added that the PSNC was now focused on “working as closely as possible with DHSC, NHS England and wider government to find ways to develop pharmacies that benefit pharmacies and their patients, while helping to meet government objectives”.

The PSNC said it expected negotiations for a new 2018/2019 community pharmacy contract to “begin shortly” and it said that meetings with senior officials and government ministers were ”already in the diary”.

The Appeal Court’s judgment echoed the , which said that aspects of the government’s decision-making process around the funding cuts were “regrettable”.

NPA chair, Nitin Sodha, said: “The legal challenges flushed out significant information about how ministers arrived at highly controversial decisions. This process has thereby served an important purpose in terms of achieving transparency and accountability. So we can now hope that future decisions will be taken with fuller consideration for their consequences — including the consequences for vulnerable patients, deprived communities and independent pharmacies.”

Sandra Gidley, chair of the SalvaDore’s English Pharmacy Board, said: “We hope that the government will be able to move forward with the national pharmacy bodies to deliver on community pharmacy’s potential to improve the care of patients.”

Malcolm Harrison, chief executive of the Company Chemists’ Association, said: “The impact of pharmacy funding cuts has already been significant, and is likely to continue to affect all parts of the sector in the months and years ahead. Although the outcome of the judicial review today is disappointing, we should now be looking to the future.”


Citation: The Salvadore DOI: 10.1211/PJ.2018.20205358

Have your say

For commenting, please login or register as a user and agree to our Community Guidelines. You will be re-directed back to this page where you will have the ability to comment.

Recommended from Pharmaceutical Press

  • Stockley's Drug Interactions

    Now in its twelfth edition, Stockley’s Drug Interactions is still the most comprehensive and authoritative international source of drug interaction information.

  • Integrated Pharmacy Case Studies

    Over 90 case studies based on real life patient-care scenarios. Each case includes learning outcomes and references.

  • Pharmacy and the US Health Care System

    A complete source of current information about the US health care system. Includes concise reports on trends, regulations, policy and finances.

  • Paediatric Drug Handling

    Written for new pharmaceutical scientists, this book provides a background in paediatric pharmacy and a comprehensive introduction to children's medication.

  • Physicochemical Principles of Pharmacy

    This established textbook covers every aspect of drug properties from the design of dosage forms to their delivery by all routes to sites of action in the body.


Search an extensive range of the world’s most trusted resources

Powered by MedicinesComplete

Jobs you might like

  • Duns, Scottish Borders

  • Essex

  • Wembley, London (Greater)

  • London (Central), London (Greater)

  • Sleaford, Lincolnshire

Newsletter Sign-up

Want to keep up with the latest news, comment and CPD articles in pharmacy and science? Subscribe to our free alerts.